Low Emotional Resilience: When Staying Plugged In Keeps You Checked Out

Earlier this year, CNN reported a rising trend of people choosing wired earbuds again, driven by convenience and a retro style. The trend has been reinforced by well-known figures in fashion and sports, making it even more appealing to younger audiences.

But even before that, earbuds had already become a constant part of daily life-used while working, studying, exercising, traveling, and even during conversations. Seeing people with earbuds in everywhere made it feel normal, almost expected. This widespread use has led to an important question: what is constant, background listening actually doing to us?

Earphone Use Linked to Anxiety, Depression, and Hearing Risks

In an article from the Noise and Health International Journal, Choi, Park, and Kim (2021) found a link between heavy earphone use (too loud, too long) and physical side effects like tinnitus. But the observed impact wasn't just physical-people who used earphones were about 32% more likely to experience anxiety or depression than those who didn't. This pattern was strongest in adults ages 21-40, especially among women.

This makes sense when you step back and think about what constant earbud use does to us as social people. If you walk up to someone wearing earbuds, you're less likely to interrupt-earbuds act like a "do not disturb" sign. That reduces everyday opportunities for connection, especially the small, spontaneous interactions that matter. Over time, this doesn't just affect relationships-it shapes the person using them.

A 2014 survey of 1,001 adults found that 45% use headphones to avoid social interaction, and 20% said they would skip a daily meal before going without them. That's a strong pull for adults-so imagine the impact on a developing teen brain. Constantly being plugged in can reduce presence, make it harder to read situations, and limit the ability to adapt socially. It also weakens tolerance for silence, discomfort, and self-reflection.

These reports have significance because low resilience and loneliness during adolescence are strong predictors of anxiety and depression later in life-and the risk increases even more when both are present. Resilience acts as a protective factor: higher resilience is linked to lower anxiety and depression, while low resilience is tied to stronger negative emotions, relationship struggles, and difficulty adjusting. Emotional resilience-the ability to handle stress, regulate emotions, and recover from challenges-is especially important. Building it early, through things like healthy routines and real-world interaction, can make a major difference in long-term mental health.

What is this really about

It's probably pretty clear that earbuds aren't at the root of low resilience; it's about what they're helping the person do: avoid and check out. And the more a person relies on them, the harder those situations can start to feel without them.

On the outside, it might look like…

• automatically putting them in when entering a space, whether it is quiet or social

• poor eye contact and avoiding conversation

• using earbuds while doing tasks that need focus

• noticeably irritable or restless when they are not in use

• leaving situations early due to discomfort (class, family time, group settings)

On the inside, it might sound like….

• "I can't focus without something playing."

• "This is too quiet… I hate this feeling."

• "I need something to distract me."

• "If I don't have my earbuds, I'll feel anxious or trapped."

• "I don't want to deal with people right now."

• "This is boring-I need stimulation."

• "I just need to get through this, then I can put them back in."

Earbuds can act like an easy and accessible escape. So can anything that habitualizes shortcuts from discomfort instead of strengthening our skills in tolerating silence, being present with personal thoughts and emotions, or managing discomfort. Resilience is like a muscle. The more we practice, the better and stronger we become. When the muscle stops being used, we lose the strength we had. If we only practice escaping, then emotions connected to anxiety, boredom, loneliness, or overstimulation become amplified.

Try this

One helpful approach is mindfulness, which means paying attention to the present moment without judging it. Simple practices like focusing on your breathing or noticing your thoughts can help you slow down and respond to stress more calmly. Over time, mindfulness can help you feel more in control, think more clearly, and stay grounded in everyday life. Here is a 5 minute video to get you started. https://youtu.be/feeDQw9K5xY?si=evJo-uVUZbfKyglE

Resources

1. Taylor, Jim (2022, Aug 30) Listen Up: Why Earbuds Are a Threat to Ourselves and Society | Psychology Today https://share.google/wQpbQx6AfknMYH3Yv

1. Choi JH, Park SS, Kim SY. (2021) Associations of Earphone Use with Tinnitus and Anxiety/Depression. Noise Health. Oct-Dec; 23(111):108-116. doi: 10.4103/nah.NAH_48_20. PMID: 34975126; PMCID: PMC8772443.

2. Bantock, Jack (2026, Jan 28) Why wired headphones are swinging back into style. CNN WORLD.https://www.cnn.com/world/wired-headphones-comeback-spc?Date=20260131&Profile=CNN&utm_content=1769879454&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwY2xjawRKMHRleHRuA2FlbQIxMABzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEeSASixDLUDT19nEYODs-Y-ZhzKfOgj0vVcH--yCzCz7I8F-y9Rt5FDdHKB1g_aem_8kvqY-F2k8QJrEDBopmWow

3. Parlikar, N., Strand, L.B., Kvaløy, K. et al. The prospective association of adolescent loneliness and low resilience with anxiety and depression in young adulthood: The HUNT study. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol60, 2223-2235 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-025-02888-2

4. Wang H, Wang M, Wang X, Feng T, Liu X, Xiao W. Complex associations between anxiety, depression, and resilience in a college student sample: a network analysis. Front Psychiatry. 2025 May 14;16:1502252. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1502252. PMID: 40438336; PMCID: PMC12117827.

5. McAdam, Emma (HOST) Mindfulness In Real Life: Learn Mindful Breathing in 2 Minutes. Therapy In A Nutshell. https://youtu.be/feeDQw9K5xY?si=evJo-uVUZbfKyglE

---

Roubicek & Thacker Counseling is Fresno’s premier provider of individual, couples, family, and group therapy. We offer in-person and online remote therapy sessions. Contact us today to change the way you feel.