“And her life will perhaps be the richer, for holding now within it the memory of what came, but could not stay.” (p. 52)
George MacDonald’s Phantastes follows a young man named Anodos, who awakens to find himself transported to a magical place called Fairy Land. During his journey, he stays in a cottage belonging to a woman he calls his hostess. Before he leaves, she warns him about the dangers of the enchanted forest. When Anodos eventually departs, he feels a bittersweet mixture of sorrow and delight as he reflects on the kindness and care she showed him. He wonders whether his leaving has made her sad, but finds comfort in the thought that her life may be richer simply because their paths crossed, even if only temporarily.
MacDonald offers a beautiful perspective on the nature of memory: not everything meaningful is meant to last, and not every meaningful experience needs to remain at the forefront of our minds to have value. Some experiences leave something behind in us, quietly shaping who we become long after the moment has passed. This is an especially comforting idea when we consider how easily joyful experiences can fade from our conscious memory, because that means the joyful things don’t leave us even if we forget to remember them. Perhaps we don’t have to remember every detail of the happiness we’ve experienced for it to have mattered. Its influence may remain in us, even when the memory itself becomes less clear. So, how do we know we have been happy or enriched, if we cannot remember it?
Have you ever been asked, “What was the happiest time in your life?” and suddenly realized you have no idea what to say?
Maybe you can name events that were supposed to be happy: a wedding, the birth of a child, spending time with friends, a graduation, a vacation, a birthday, a new job. You may even know, logically, that you enjoyed them. But when you try to remember what happiness actually felt like during those moments, there is nothing there. No warm feeling. No clear picture. Sometimes not even a particular moment comes to mind. For some people, the conclusion becomes, Maybe I was never genuinely happy.
Forgetting to Remember
The beginning quote by MacDonald was an observation integrated into a story, but modern studies have examined the transitory nature of even our most special moments.
Research by Stephanie Tully and Tom Meyvis suggests that people routinely overestimate how much they will remember and talk about enjoyable experiences. Participants expected memorable experiences to remain on their minds, but months later, they were thinking about them much less than they had predicted. C.S. Lewis noted in his book Mere Christianity that human memory is passively fragile. If we do not actively “feed” our thoughts (or in the case of Tully and Meyvis’s research, purposefully talk about and revisit our positive experiences), they naturally fade, no matter how profound or joyful they initially seemed.
The researchers described it simply: people can “forget to remember.” The experience hasn’t necessarily become meaningless. It has simply become less accessible as everyday life, responsibilities, distractions, and newer experiences take up attention. Interestingly, visible reminders, such as physical souvenirs or professional photographs, helped people revisit those experiences more often than simply having digital photographs available (Tully & Meyvis, 2017; USC Marshall School of Business, 2017). Could it be that some of us mistake forgotten happiness for a life in which happiness was never really there? What if the problem isn’t that we haven’t experienced enough happiness, but that we expect happiness to remember itself?
Depression Can Convince
When someone is depressed, remembering a happy experience isn’t entirely the same thing as remembering the facts of what happened. A person might remember getting married, taking a vacation, or laughing with friends while having little or no access to the emotional experience that went with those events, thus making the idea of maybe I never really was happy more convincing.
This has been described in terms of mood-congruent memory and state-dependent memory. Our current emotional state can influence which memories come to mind and what those memories feel like when we retrieve them. When someone is deeply depressed, negative or painful memories may be easier to access, while memories associated with happiness can feel distant or emotionally flat. Many people with depression report this experience as knowing logically that they experienced periods outside depression while being unable to emotionally remember what that felt like when they were depressed.
It’s a particularly cruel illusion: If I can’t remember feeling happy, maybe I never was happy. Depression can make the present feel like evidence about the entire past, when it’s not. The strange thing about emotional memory is that it isn’t a perfect recording of our lives. It is something the brain continually reconstructs.
Research on emotional episodic memory has found that emotion can influence what aspects of an experience are retained and later recollected. Emotional information can become particularly durable over time, while contextual details (the surrounding circumstances, where we were, what happened immediately before or afterward) may be more difficult to retrieve. Researchers have proposed that emotional experiences become linked with specific aspects of an event in ways that can make some parts of the memory more accessible than others (Yonelinas & Ritchey, 2015).
So you may remember that you were happy without being able to remember how you were happy. Or you may remember the restaurant but not the laughter. You may remember the photograph but not the feeling you had when it was taken. Sometimes the memory is there. The feeling attached to it is what is difficult to reach. And sometimes people really do feel as though happiness never happened. This experience isn’t limited to people with a formal diagnosis of depression.
People describe going through life functioning reasonably well while feeling emotionally flat, disconnected, or unable to identify a time when they experienced sustained happiness. One person described being able to appear happy in school and work while privately feeling that something was missing. Another described depression as somehow “staining backward,” making previously happy memories difficult to experience as happy when viewed from a depressed state.
There is something important in those accounts: the absence of an accessible happy memory does not necessarily mean the absence of a happy experience. It may mean that happiness wasn’t noticed, wasn’t revisited, wasn’t strongly encoded, has become difficult to retrieve, or is currently being viewed through a depressed emotional state. And sometimes it may mean that someone really has been struggling for a very long time and deserves help figuring out why. Those possibilities can coexist.
What Can We Do With This?
One useful place to start is to stop demanding a “happiest moment.” That question is enormous. It can make a person search their entire life for one dramatic piece of evidence that they have been happy. Try something smaller. Instead of asking when was I truly happy, try asking these questions instead:
When did I laugh harder than I expected?
Who made me feel comfortable?
What place did I enjoy being?
What music made me feel something?
When did I look forward to seeing someone?
What food, smell, movie, or song brings back a pleasant feeling?
When have I felt peaceful (or a lack of chaos), even if I wouldn’t call it happy?
When did I lose track of time because I was absorbed in something healthy?
What is one ordinary day I wouldn’t mind experiencing again?
Happiness doesn’t always announce itself. Sometimes it looks more like relief, amusement, connection, curiosity, contentment, or feeling completely absorbed in something for twenty minutes.
It can help to deliberately collect those moments. Write them down. Keep a photograph somewhere visible. Save a ticket, postcard, recipe, note, or other physical reminder. Tell someone about the experience. Revisit the music that was playing. This isn’t manufacturing a fake happy past. It will offer your brain more opportunities to find what is already there, and practice not dismissing small happy things.
“Owning our story and loving ourselves through that process is the bravest thing that we will ever do.” (Brown, 2010)
Life is more complicated than simply saying, “I was happy” or “I wasn’t.” As MacDonald suggests, experiences can enrich our lives even when they don’t remain as clear, accessible memories. Maybe there were good moments you have forgotten, moments that mattered more than you realized, or experiences that depression has made difficult to recall. Perhaps you have spent years functioning while feeling emotionally disconnected from your own life.
You are strong enough to make room for all of it, including the parts you struggle to remember. Your story is still being written. There are meaningful experiences ahead that may become cherished memories, even if you cannot imagine them yet.
Not remembering happiness is worth paying attention to, especially when accompanied by persistent sadness, numbness, loss of interest, or hopelessness. These can be signs of depression and are worth discussing with a qualified professional. But a blank space in your memory is not necessarily a verdict on your life. You don’t have to remember every moment of happiness for it to have mattered. Its influence may remain in who you are, even when the memory itself becomes harder to reach.
References
MacDonald, G (1894) Phantastes. Free PDF at https://archive.org/details/phantastesfaerie00macduoft/page/66/mode/2up
Why Do Your Happy Memories Fade? https://share.google/9OCieZTE0bos6CgHQ
How Depression Affects Memory: Why You Can’t Remember Being Happy, Natasha Tracy, Bipolar Expert. https://share.google/vQfgLghPScaAwx6x6
The slow forgetting of emotional episodic memories: An emotional binding account, PMC. https://share.google/dSWg3mYdtK8Q6BXg2
Roubicek & Thacker Counseling is Fresno’s premier provider of individual, couples, family, and group therapy. We offer in-person and online remote therapy sessions. Contact us today to change the way you feel.